The Edit

Every verdict we've ever published.

37 stories
VerdictsLatest
Chlöe Bailey's Toronto Film Festival shoes: gold Aquazzura platforms, and the twin for $40.60.
Updated Sep 23, 2026 · Heels
SPLURGE$148
STEAL$39.99
vs
Splurge vs. StealHeels
Schutz Lou vs. the $39 Amazon stiletto: one of these gets you home, and one does not
Updated Aug 9, 2026
SPLURGE$180
STEAL$65
vs
Splurge vs. StealBoots
The Sam Edelman Shauna vs. the $65 Amazon version: which knee-high boot deserves your money?
Updated Aug 9, 2026
VerdictsHeels
Selena Gomez's New York shoes this week: white Gianvito Rossi pumps, and the twin for $41.99.
Updated Sep 20, 2026
VerdictsHeels
Amal Clooney's Venice 2026 shoes: Tom Ford Vertigo pumps, and the twin for $39.99.
Updated Sep 19, 2026
VerdictsHeels
Sydney Sweeney's Venice 2026 shoes: clear Gianvito Rossi mules, and the twin for $36.99.
Updated Sep 18, 2026
VerdictsHeels
Sarah Michelle Gellar's Emmys 2026 shoes: Jimmy Choo Max silver platforms, and the twin for $43.99.
Updated Sep 17, 2026
VerdictsHeels
Mariska Hargitay's Emmys 2026 shoes: Stuart Weitzman red platforms, and the twin for $38.69.
Updated Sep 16, 2026
VerdictsHeels
Zendaya's Emmys 2026 shoes: pale pink satin Prada pumps, and the twin for $69.99.
Updated Sep 15, 2026
VerdictsHeels
Ruby Reacts: Venice Film Festival shoes. Two wrong, one right.
Updated Sep 12, 2026
GuidesHeels
One sage bridesmaid dress, eight shoes. Which number?
Updated Sep 11, 2026
GuidesHeels
Three suits, six shoes, three rules for Monday morning.
Updated Sep 10, 2026
GuidesHeels
Three pairs of jeans, six shoes, three rules for jeans season.
Updated Sep 9, 2026
GuidesHeels
Three wedding dresses, six shoes, three rules every bride learns too late.
Updated Sep 8, 2026
GuidesHeels
Three outfits, six shoes, three rules you will actually use this autumn.
Updated Sep 7, 2026
VerdictsHeels
One black slip dress, three shoes, and only one of them is right.
Updated Sep 6, 2026
TrendsFlats
Six colours, one shoe. The black one disappears.
Updated Aug 29, 2026
TrendsBoots
Harper's Bazaar said western boots got refined. This is what that means.
Updated Aug 28, 2026
TrendsFlats
Four stars. I am posting it anyway, and here is why.
Updated Aug 27, 2026
TrendsBoots
The tall boot is back, and the slouchy one is the one to have.
Updated Aug 26, 2026
TrendsFlats
Thirty five dollars. Look at them again.
Updated Aug 25, 2026
TrendsHeels
She won an award in these. They cost $45.57.
Updated Aug 24, 2026
TrendsBoots
The ankle boot is not the story this fall. This is.
Updated Aug 23, 2026
TrendsBoots
That leopard isn't printed on. It's fur.
Updated Aug 22, 2026
TrendsHeels
The Mary Jane came back, and it brought a platform with it
Updated Aug 21, 2026
TrendsBoots
Look again — that is not a boot
Updated Aug 20, 2026
TrendsBoots
Suede is the fall 2026 boot, and cognac is the colour
Updated Aug 19, 2026
TrendsHeels
Megan Thee Stallion wore a $200 ballet heel into the Love Island villa
Updated Aug 18, 2026
TrendsHeels
The most-searched heel right now isn't a stiletto
Updated Aug 17, 2026
TrendsBoots
Burgundy is the colour of fall, and this is the shape it wants to be
Updated Aug 16, 2026
TrendsHeels
A $140 wedding-guest heel is now $42, and the reason is the calendar
Updated Aug 15, 2026
TrendsBoots
SZA wore a work boot on a four-inch stiletto
Updated Aug 14, 2026
TrendsBoots
Horse girl fall is real — and this is the boot everyone means
Updated Aug 13, 2026
TrendsHeels
The hottest shoe in the world is a $990 flip flop
Updated Aug 12, 2026
TrendsBoots
The 3 boots that will own fall 2026 — all under $70
Updated Aug 10, 2026
VerdictsBoots
The $49 white rhinestone cowboy boots all over your feed — worth it?
Updated Aug 8, 2026
VerdictsBoots
These $49 black western boots look designer — here's the catch
Updated Aug 7, 2026